“The Ultimate Fighter: Team Carwin vs. Team Nelson” returned to action tonight on FX. This week marked the second fight in the house with coach Shane Carwin selecting the second bout after Team Carwin’s Neil Magney defeated Team Nelson’s Cameron Diffley. “TUF 16″will air every Friday night until the live finale on December 1 as 16 welterweights vie to become “The Ultimate Fighter.”SPOILERS BELOW
This week’s episode picked where last week’s episode left off, with Team Carwin basking in Magney’s victory and Team Nelson getting a little tense knowing they lost fight selection. Nelson hoped that last week’s loss prompted his team to listen more during their fights, but it appeared the team was more paranoid over who would be picked to fight next.
Back at the house, another round of verbal sparring began, once again involving Team Carwin’s Matt Secor. Secor’s annoyance of Team Nelson lead to Colton Smith wishing to fight Secor to shut him up. Later on, Team Nelson’s Nic Herron-Webb decided it was a good idea to play pool late at night and be as loud as humanly possible in an effort to annoy Team Carwin. The effort paid off, as Team Carwin demanded he quiet down and questioned his ability to fight. Mike Ricci appeared very interested in facing Herron-Webb after the incident.
With those two incidents shown, it came time for fight selection. With Coach Shane Carwin selecting his number-one overall pick, “Smilin’” Sam Alvey, to face Team Nelson’s Joey Rivera. The selection put the aforementioned grudge matches on hold for the moment.
Back at the house, Team Nelson’s fighters informed Herron-Webb that they were annoyed by his late night antics as well. Herron-Webb seemed to blow off their frustrations however.
Before the fight, Team Nelson decides they should mess with Alvey before his fight with Rivera, with Julian Lane insisting they throw his mattress into the pool. Lane was outvoted though, and the mattress was floated on rafts instead. The prank appeared to have little effect on Alvey however, but teammate Igor Araujo was clearly heated with action.
Sam Alvey vs. Joey Rivera
In the fight of the week, a brief bit of early striking gave way to a grappling match to kick off the first round. While Alvey was game, Rivera attacked with multiple submission attempts. The closest of which was a guillotine choke that was very deep before Alvey escaped. Alvey eventually got on top finished the round with some strong shots, but Rivera appeared to have the edge going into Round 2.
Alvey started off round two better, connecting with punches before a failed attempt at getting the fight to the ground. The fight turned into a clinch battle for awhile, with Roy Nelson trying to coach his fighter into a more secure guillotine attempt that never materialized. The biggest shot of the fight then came later in the round as Alvey, looking to push the pace after a restart by referee Herb Dean, was wobbled by a vicious headkick by Rivera. That led to a brief Rivera takedown before Alvey got back to his feet and tried to steal the round with a late takedown of his own.
The effort was to no avail however, as the judges awarded Rivera a majority decision in a fight that appeared to be heading to a third round.
The Team Nelson win tied up the competition at 1-1.
Team Carwin
Sam Alvey(lost to Joey Rivera)- Bristol Marunde
- Mike Ricci
- Neil Magny def. Cameron Diffly via unanimous decision (20-18, 20-18,20-18)
- James Chaney
- Eddie Ellis
- Igor Araujo
- Matt Secor
Team Nelson
- Dom Waters
- Michael Hill
Cameron Diffley(lost to Neil Magny)- Colton Smith
- Jon Manley
- Nic Herron-Webb
- Joey Rivera def. Sam Alvey via Majority Decision (19-19,20-18,20-18)
- Julian Lane




I don’t understand why Shane Carwin is even on this show?
He’s suppose to be a coach yet he doesn’t coach his fighters, doesn’t corner his fighters, heck doesn’t even seem to get in the cage and practice with his fighters. He has a team that does everything for him, so why be on the show in the first place?
I think it was a bad selection for a coach by Dana White. He can give Roy Nelson a hard time all he wants, but at least Roy Nelson has a clue what is going on in these fights and can somewhat coach his fighters. Carwin is absolutely useless.
That is all I have to say.
I see your point, but he did bring in an amazing crew to work with the guys. Though I certainly agree it does not fit what the coaches have done in previous seasons.
As an added note, I believe Carwin actually had little interest in being a coach for this season but they needed coaches so bad they forced it.
Carwin did say that he is not a cornerman. He will let the people who have experience giving instructions during a fight handle it. He said he is not here for the tv time and that him not in the corner gives his team the best chance to win.
The fight should have gone to a third round. How the hell could 2 of the judges say River won the 2nd round? He did literally no damage that round aside from a couple head kicks. Alvey was in control for most of the round, landing how many unanswered punches and knees? I honestly lost count. He also had more succesful takedowns and did more damage while on the ground. That was a crap decision.
Since the friday switch I have not watched the ultimate fighter since! It needs to switch back to Wednesday’s!